Results

*Plaintiff’s alleged damages are not reflective of what the plaintiff actually asked for at trial but only past economic damages including health care expenses, property damage, and lost wages.

 


Cause No. JS-09-00090-D; Marina Del-Carmen Huezo vs. Alejo Martinez, as filed in the Small Claims Court, Precinct 2, Place 1, in Dallas County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $6311.00
Jury verdict: $2000.00


Cause No. 2009-1-116CV, Government Employees Insurance Company vs. Cody Mills, as filed in the County Court at Law No. 1, Grayson County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $5051.88
Jury verdict: $0


Cause No. SC00014744; Karen Hathcock vs. Carlos Soto, as filed in the Justice of the Peace Court, Precinct 2, in Tarrant County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $3309.57
Jury verdict: $4000.000


Cause No: 017-227992-07, Marie McKinney vs. Brenda Woods, as filed in 17th Judicial District Court of Tarrant County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $8942.00
Jury verdict: $12,117.78


Cause No. 09-07237, Veronica Ventura, et al vs. Raymundo Gallegos, as filed in 192nd Judicial District Court of Dallas County, Dallas, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $12,506.05
Jury verdict: $0


Cause No. SC51C0105972, Evelyn Winata vs. Maria Mayen, as filed in the Small Claims Court, Precinct 5, Place 1, of Harris County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $2000.00
Jury verdict: $1500.00


Cause No. 09-76635-2, Rigoberto Baca, et al v. Ruth Trujillo, et al, as filed in the County Court at Law No. 2, Tarrant County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $2415.00
Jury verdict: $0


Cause No. 09-73712-1; John Cole, Jr. and John Cole, Sr. vs. Sandra Serna and Jose G. Campos; as filed in the County Court at Law No. 1, Tarrant County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $17,176.66
Jury verdict: $500.00


Cause No. CC-2008-068312-1; Patricia Fant, et al v. Michael Hudson; as filed in the County Court at Law No. 1, Tarrant County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $6641.52
Jury verdict: $0


Cause No. DC-09-11058, Dorothy Hendrix, Individually and a/n/f of Jameka Haskins, as filed in the 134th Judicial District Court of Dallas County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $13,244.35
Jury verdict: $8473.95


Cause No: 141-236315-09, Emanuel Roland vs. Esiquiel Falcon, as filed in the 141st Judicial District Court of Tarrant County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $22,277.88
Jury verdict: $4000.00


Cause No, CC-10-05861-D, Lisa Thomas v. Jose F. Frausto and Lorenzo Carranza, in the County Court at Law No. 4, Dallas County, Texas.

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $10,406.77
Jury verdict: $0


Cause No. CC-10-05837-B, Enrique Gudino, Eliza Gudino and Maria Gonzales v. Marlon Pinales-Ruano, as filed in the County Court at Law No. 2 of Dallas County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $67,277.00
Jury verdict: $0


Cause No. DC-11-02992, Delbert Knight, Sr., Anthony Knight vs. Ana Martinez and Armando Casiano Chavarria as filed in the 298th Judicial District of Dallas, County, Texas.

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $33,420.22
Jury verdict: $1764.22


Cause No. 2010-51971, Gladys Nunez v. Antonio Chimeo, as filed in the 334th District Court of Harris County, Texas.

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $3356.10
Jury verdict: $0


Cause No. JCH-000428 Stacey Williams vs. Rachel Willingham as filed in the Justice Court, Precinct 5-2, Dallas County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $8546.10
Jury verdict: $2701.58


Cause No. 348-254212-11 Daphne Powell vs. Edith Cervantes as filed in the 348th Judicial District Court of Tarrant County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $8844.25
Jury verdict: $4100.00


Cause No. 11-07040-D Epigmenio Barron and Rosario Barron vs. Melissa Yvette Jimenez as filed in the County Court at Law No. 4 of Dallas County, Texas

Plaintiff’s alleged economic damages: $23,759.00
Jury verdict: $8670.00


 

Total alleged economic damages: $255,485.35 Total Jury Verdicts: $48,327.53

**Over this period of time juries awarded less than the alleged economic damages 89% of the time. **

**When the juries did award damages on average they awarded 33% of the plaintiff’s alleged economic damages.**